Limited Edition!
.png)
Mini Easter Sugar Pillows
Our Signature Sugar Pillows in miniature eggs shapes are big on delicious and make a very thoughtful gift for anyone or to keep for yourself!
$12 per dozen
Seasonal Shape
Signature Sugar Pillow Eggs
Don't forget our Signature Sugar Pillows are available as eggs to celebrate the season! Perfect for Easter celebrations, office break room, as an accompaniment with flowers and other gifts, or just because you like them!
$14 per dozen
New Menu Item!
Chocolate Sampler Pack
May all your chocolate dreams come true with this fun Sampler box full of chocolatey goodness! Featuring familiar favorites of Seasonal Monsters, Chocolate Chip Softies and our Signature Sugar Pillows with chocolate trim, along with these new flavors to enjoy of Scotcheroo Sweeties, Chocolate Chunkies, and delicious buckeye-candy-inspired O-H-I-O Cookies! You're gonna love it!
$22 per box
New!
.png){kind=small}
_edited.png){kind=small}
O-H-I-O Cookies
Proud to live in Ohio, proud to serve customers in Ohio, and proud to be an Ohio small business, it's only fitting that we turn the beloved buckeye candy of a chocolate-wrapped peanut butter goodie into a cookie! This delicious chocolate cookie topped with peanut butter, topped with chocolate, topped with peanut butter cups is a sure winner! Just like some other Ohio Buckeyes we know!
$24/dozen
New!
OatNeal Creme Smackdown
Inspired by a request from a special customer named Neal, this yummy treat is made with two Oatmeal cookies smacked together with a creamy middle. This is our idea of creme de la creme (chef's kiss)!
$5 each
New!
New!
Highlander Grogger Coffee Cookies
Calling all coffee lovers! This coffee-inspired original cookie includes all the subtle flavors of Highlander Grogg coffee, including caramel, chocolate, rum, almonds, and of course, coffee!
$15 per dozen
Signature Flavors
Sugar Pillows
Our signature cookie. A melt-in-your-mouth sugar cookie topped with just the right amount of buttercream frosting,
your choice of pastel color. Where our cookie business started – literally thousands have been made through the years!
Select seasonal shapes available. $14 per dozen
Chocolate Chip Softies
A soft golden chewy chocolate chip cookie, nearly everyone’s favorite.
$14 per dozen
Chomp Chomp Monsters
Chocolate Chunks, Oatmeal, M&M’s, Peanut Butter, Pretzels...so many favorite flavors in one addictive cookie!
$14 per dozen
​Momma's Molasses
Sugar coated, soft, lightly spiced flavor molasses cookie, sure to conjure up memories of Grandma.
$14 per dozen
Dipped Trifecta
A chocolate cookie with chocolate chips, dipped in white chocolate. So yummy!
$14 per dozen
​Doodled Snickerdoodles
Yummy cinnamon and sugar wrapped goodness snickerdoodle cookie, topped with doodled white icing.
Excellent with a cup of coffee!
$14 per dozen
Premium Flavors
​Glazed Oatmeal Raisin
Sugar, spice, and everything nice like hearty oatmeal and plump raisins make this chewy cookie good enough to
be called a customer new favorite.
$14 per dozen
Mmm Mmm Candy Cookies
Candy meets Cookie in this fun and yummy treat! Seasonal and holiday candy colors available.
$14 per dozen
Peanut Butter Yummies
If you love peanut butter, this cookie is for you! A soft, delicious, puffy peanut butter cookie striped with peanut butter frosting and topped with peanut butter chips. Every bite is a peanut butter dream!
$14 per dozen
Butter Pecan Cookies
Welcome to our new favorite cookie! This butter-rich and nutty cookie is topped with a maple glaze, toffee, and more nuts. Well worth a slightly higher price due to more pricey ingredients at $15 per dozen.
Salted Caramel Dark Chocolate Dreams
Originally a Christmas special, now a permanent addition to our premium cookie list to bring you joy all year round!
A delicious mix of caramel and lots of chocolate! $21 per dozen
Lemon Zesties
Who knew lemon plus cookie could be so good? A fresh lemon in every batch make these a delightfully refreshing treat!
$15 per dozen
Chocolate Silk Cookies
These rich chocolate cookies are velvety soft with a smooth chocolate ganache and topped with tiny chocolate curls.
$16 per dozen
Frosted Pumpkin Drops
Enjoy pumpkin spice all year long! Covered with a thick layer of cream cheese flavored frosting and cinnamon sprinkles, these are truly pumpkin spice and everything nice! $15 per dozen
Sunshine and Lemonade
By making a few happy recipe changes to our Lemon Zesties, we created these fun Blueberry Lemonade and Strawberry Lemonade cookies, paired with simple sunshine decorated Signature Sugar Pillows! Special packaging makes this a delightful gift box to brighten anyone's day, including yours! Includes 3 each of our Signature Sugar Pillows, along with our new Lemon Zesties, Blueberry Lemonade and Strawberry Lemonade cookies.
$18 per dozen
Great Big Cookies
Baked in a pie pan but smaller than a pizza, our Great Big Cookie is big enough to share (but doesn't have to be!) and edge-topped with buttercream frosting.
Try our Great Big Chocolate Chip Softie Cookie with your choice of caramel candy pieces, peanut butter cup candy pieces, or milk chocolate candies as frosting toppers for extra indulgence.
OR
Try our Great Big Lemon Zestie Cookie with lemon, blueberry, and strawberry buttercream frosting around the edge, topped with lemon wafer candy.
Great Big Cookies make deliciously fun gifts and yummy party menu additions. Tastefully packaged in an 8-inch box, these Great Big Cookies will surely bring great big smiles!
$18 each​
Variety Pack 'n More than Cookies
Cinnamon Swirl Sweet Rolls
We've got your breakfast and brunch sweet tooth covered with these delicious and soft sweet rolls. Packed with cinnamon, and frosted with lots of yummy icing; your choice with or without nut topping. $3 each.
Variety Pack
Can't decide which flavor? Try this fun and delicious Variety Pack with your choice of any combination of the above flavors to create your own custom cookie dozen. $14 per dozen
(Inclusion of Butter Pecan Cookies and Salted Caramel Dark Chocolate Dreams in Variety Pack may reflect slight price increase)
Our “Just Right” size cookie is the perfect pairing with a cup of coffee, to serve as a dessert, to have at a light
luncheon, or to eat just for fun! We think it’s so perfectly sized you might even have room for more than one!
Payment can be made in the form of Cash or Check made out to: Cookie 'n a Coffee and will be received upon delivery.
Please allow 3 days from order to delivery for us to prepare your cookies to perfection.